menu icon
subscribe
search icon
One Basic Cookie Dough Recipe →

15 Nutter Butter Christmas Cookie Ideas

Modified: · Published: by · This post may contain affiliate links · Leave a Comment

Turn ordinary cookies into festive treats with these Nutter Butter Christmas Cookie Ideas!

From snowmen and reindeer to chocolate-dipped truffles, each recipe is fun, easy, and perfect for holiday trays or edible gifts.

Get ready to add some peanut butter sweetness to your Christmas Cookie baking lineup.

Nutter Butter Christmas Cookie Ideas

At-a-Glance: Festive Nutter Butter Holiday Cookies

What You’ll Find: A collection of festive, creative ways to transform Nutter Butter cookies into adorable holiday treats like snowmen, reindeer, and chocolate-dipped truffles.

Why You’ll Love It: Each idea is simple, fun to make with kids, and guaranteed to bring peanut butter flavor and holiday cheer to your cookie trays.

Perfect For: Cookie exchanges, classroom parties, or adding a playful touch to your Christmas dessert spread.

Time-Saver Tip: Stock up on Nutter Butters early and decorate in batches—most of these cookies freeze beautifully for make-ahead holiday baking.

👉Click HERE to grab my NEW Christmas Cookie Exchange Printables

Table of Contents

Helpful Tips for Making Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies for Christmas

Decorating Nutter Butter cookies is such a fun and easy way to get into the holiday spirit! Before you start dipping and decorating, here are a few helpful tips to make the process smooth and stress-free.

  • Use candy melts or almond bark instead of regular chocolate chips. They melt smoothly and set quickly, making them ideal for decorating.
  • Let cookies cool completely after dipping before adding small candy decorations like eyes, buttons, or sprinkles so they stay in place.
  • Chill decorated cookies on a parchment-lined baking sheet for about 10–15 minutes to help the coating set before packaging or stacking.
  • Work in small batches if you’re using multiple colors of candy melts to keep each bowl smooth and easy to work with.
  • For gifting or cookie trays, line boxes with parchment or tissue paper to protect your decorated cookies and prevent smudging.

Looking for more easy cookies to make for the holidays that are fun? Try my Christmas Cookies with Oreos or my collection of adorable Reindeer Desserts.

Nutter Butter Christmas Cookie Ideas

Microwave-Safe Bowls – Ideal for melting candy melts or chocolate coating in small batches.

Parchment Paper or Silicone Baking Mats – Keeps cookies from sticking and makes cleanup quick.

Baking Sheets or Trays – Use for dipping, decorating, and chilling the cookies as they set.

Forks or Dipping Tools – Helps lift the cookies neatly from the melted coating without mess.

Small Squeeze Bottles or Piping Bags – Perfect for adding chocolate drizzle or fine decorative details.

Cooling Rack – Lets cookies set evenly after decorating.

Everyday cooking tools.

👉 Explore the full collection...

My Essential Kitchen Tools

Tools to make baking and cooking easier every day.

You need this list

Recipe FAQ's

To view the answers, simply click on the down arrow (⬇) next to each question. If you have any other questions not answered here, please leave a comment!

What’s the best way to melt chocolate or candy melts for dipping?

Microwave in short 20–30 second intervals, stirring between each until smooth. Overheating can cause the coating to seize or turn grainy.

How do I keep the decorations from smudging or falling off?

Let the coating cool slightly before adding decorations, and chill the cookies after decorating to help everything set firmly.

Can I use other cookies besides Nutter Butters?

Yes! Oval or sandwich-style cookies work best—like Vienna Fingers or store-brand peanut butter sandwich cookies.

Pinterest button to save this recipe.
Nutter Butter Christmas Cookie Ideas
christmas cookie ebook bundle.
Promo button I need this.

LOVE these recipes? SAVE them for Later!

❤️Tap the heart icon in the lower right corner to add this collection to your personal recipe box for easy access anytime.

⭐Tried some of them already? Don't forget to leave a review and star rating! Your support helps me continue creating and sharing free recipes for you to enjoy!

👉 Love printing recipes? Keep them neat and organized in my Ultimate Meal Planner & Recipe Binder—your go-to spot for all your family favorites.

Nutter Butter Snowman Cookies

These charming snowman cookies made from Nutter Butters turn a simple treat into an adorable winter-themed dessert with minimal effort. Decorated with candy details and no baking required, they’re great for kids’ activities or festive snack trays. The design brings a touch of whimsy to any holiday celebration.
Make this recipe
5 from 1 vote
nutter butter chocolate.

Nutter Butter Reindeer Cookies

With pretzel antlers and candy features, these reindeer cookies give Nutter Butters a playful holiday makeover. They're quick to assemble, making them a fun project for families or classroom treats. Their no-bake simplicity adds to their charm and convenience.
Make this recipe
Be the first to rate it!
Peanut butter cookies transformed into adorable reindeer with pretzel antlers and candy eyes.

Chocolate Reindeer Cookies

This chocolate-covered version of reindeer cookies offers a richer, more indulgent twist on the classic Nutter Butter design. The use of melted chocolate and festive candy makes them both eye-catching and satisfying. They're a sweet way to blend decorative fun with bold flavor.
Make this recipe
Be the first to rate it!
Reindeer cookies made with chocolate covered peanut butter cookies.

Nutter Butter Balls

Crushed Nutter Butters combined with cream cheese and dipped in chocolate create a rich, truffle-like treat that’s perfect for the holidays. These bite-sized balls are indulgent yet simple to make, ideal for gifting or serving at parties. Their creamy texture and familiar flavor make them a crowd favorite.
Make this recipe
Photo credit: https://cookingwithcarlee.com/nutter-butter-balls/
Nutter Butter Balls

Nutter Butter Christmas Cookies

This festive roundup showcases several holiday cookie designs using Nutter Butters, from Santas to snowmen and reindeer. Each idea is easy to assemble and brings creativity to the dessert table. It’s a playful collection that makes seasonal baking both fun and accessible.
Make this recipe
Photo credit: https://www.servedupwithlove.com/2015/12/nutter-butter-christmas-cookies.html
Nutter Butter Christmas Cookies

Angel Nutter Butter Cookies

These angel-themed cookies use Nutter Butters as a base to create a sweet and serene holiday treat, complete with candy wings and halos. They're a thoughtful addition to religious celebrations or Christmas platters. Their delicate look makes them especially appealing for gifting.
Make this recipe
Photo credit: https://blogghetti.com/angel-nutter-butter-cookies/
Angel Nutter Butter Cookies

Santa Nutter Butter Cookies

Featuring red frosting and mini marshmallow beards, these cookies dress up Nutter Butters as jolly Santas. The design is simple but striking, making them great for cookie exchanges or kids’ parties. They're as fun to decorate as they are to eat.
Make this recipe
Photo credit: https://blogghetti.com/santa-nutter-butter-cookies/
Santa Nutter Butter Cookies

How to make Christmas Reindeer Nutter Butter Cookies

This reindeer-themed treat turns peanut-shaped cookies into adorable characters with pretzels and candies for features. No baking is involved, so they’re perfect for last-minute holiday prep. The hands-on nature makes them ideal for kids and family activities.
Make this recipe
Photo credit: https://thetiptoefairy.com/how-to-make-christmas-reindeer-nutter-butter-cookies/
How to make Christmas Reindeer Nutter Butter Cookies

Grinch Nutter Butters

Inspired by the beloved holiday character, these Grinch cookies use Nutter Butters coated in green with a bright red heart candy. The bold colors and simple design make them perfect for themed movie nights or festive gatherings. They bring a fun, mischievous twist to Christmas treats.
Make this recipe
Photo credit: https://www.mooshujenne.com/grinch-nutter-butters/
Grinch Nutter Butters

Nutter Butter Reindeer Cupcakes

Cupcakes topped with reindeer-decorated Nutter Butters offer a playful, layered dessert perfect for holiday parties. The combination of soft cake and crunchy cookie adds variety in both texture and presentation. They're sure to stand out on any dessert table.
Make this recipe
Photo credit: https://funmoneymom.com/nutter-butter-reindeer-cupcakes/
Nutter Butter Reindeer Cupcakes

Mischievous Grinch Nutter Butter Cookies

These colorful cookies transform Nutter Butters into green Grinch faces with red hearts for a simple but festive snack. They're easy to prepare and make a great companion to holiday movie nights or themed events. Kids will especially enjoy helping bring the character to life.
Make this recipe
Photo credit: https://thrivinginparenting.com/grinch-nutter-butter-cookies/
Mischievous Grinch Nutter Butter Cookies

How to Make Grinch Nutter Butter Cookies

With bright green candy coating and a single red heart, these cookies channel the spirit of the Grinch in a sweet, edible form. Using Nutter Butters as the base, the recipe is both quick and fun to make. It’s a creative way to celebrate a holiday favorite.
Make this recipe
Photo credit: https://www.designdazzle.com/how-to-make-grinch-nutter-butter-cookies/
How to Make Grinch Nutter Butter Cookies

Holiday Reindeer Cookies

Simple ingredients come together to create festive reindeer faces using Nutter Butters, candy, and pretzels. These cookies are great for entertaining, gifting, or classroom celebrations. Their minimal prep and charming look make them a seasonal hit.
Make this recipe
Photo credit: https://domesticsuperhero.com/holiday-reindeer-cookies/
Holiday Reindeer Cookies

Nutter Butter Snowmen

Coated in white chocolate and decorated with candy, these snowmen cookies use Nutter Butters to capture winter magic in edible form. Their cheerful appearance makes them perfect for parties or cookie trays. They're a playful and easy holiday project.
Make this recipe
Photo credit: https://www.lifeloveliz.com/nutter-butter-snowmen/

Reindeer Nutter Butters

These adorable reindeer cookies, made with Nutter Butters and pretzel antlers, offer a quick way to create a festive treat that both kids and adults will enjoy. They're a great option for cookie decorating stations or homemade holiday gifts. The simplicity and charm are hard to resist.
Make this recipe
Photo credit: https://www.emiliorecipes.com/adorable-reindeer-nutter-butters-butters-everyone-will-love/
Reindeer Nutter Butters

About Lois

Originally from Queens, NY, Lois is the voice behind Walking on Sunshine Recipes, where she shares easy, family-friendly meals made with simple ingredients. She believes dinner doesn’t have to be complicated to be delicious and offers practical recipes, monthly meal plans, and free printables to help busy families cook with less stress and more joy. When she’s not in the kitchen, Lois enjoys time with her family, gardening and sharing inspiration from her home in rural Pennsylvania.

Comments

No Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

My Cart
0
Add Coupon Code
Subtotal
Checkout